How to Fix an Undercooked Apple Pie

Perfecting your baking skills is no easy feat. The path to perfection is often marred by mistakes that can make you give up on your quest. However, with the proper skills and knowledge, you can always come out successful no matter the errors you make. In this post, you will learn how to fix an undercooked apple pie and the causes. But first, what is an apple pie? Well, it is simply a pie whose core ingredient is apples. To bake the perfect apple pie, you need to understand the causes and how to prevent them.

How to Fix an Undercooked Apple Pie

How to Fix an Undercooked Apple Pie

What is an undercooked apple pie? Simply put, this is a pie that does not fulfil the recommended baking standards hence it turns out to be problematic. Since mistakes are not planned for, they can arise even with the most gifted bakers. Learning the causes of the errors and solutions to fix them will ensure you build incredible baking skills. Below are scenarios of how a pie can be undercooked and how to solve them.

1. Soggy Bottom

When baking apple pies, there is one cardinal process that ought to be followed. The dough should always be cold before it is placed in the oven. To avoid a soggy bottom, ensure that your pie is fully baked. The recommended baking technique is to ensure the oven is preheated before you place your dough. To ascertain whether your pie is fully baked, it should be golden brown. In addition, ensure that the filling you plan on using is not watery. More to that, ensure you use the appropriate pan. The best pan to use is a Pyrex glass pan that allows you to see the bottom of the pie.

Other quick tips that can prevent your apple pie from having a soggy bottom is dusting the bottom of the pie with groundnuts or flour. This will help absorb any liquid that may drip from the filling. More to that, you can also brush with a beaten egg to form an impenetrable layer that locks out any dripping juices.

2. Mushy Pie

Mushy Pie

The major reason for your pie turning mushy is using overripe apples. Overripe apples have a rigid texture and contain lots of juices that can cause your pie to be mushy when baked. Overripe apples are best suited for a chilled pie. The remedy for such an error is to check the juice content in the apples before you can use them. In addition, you will need to equip yourself with knowledge on apples suited for baking.

The apples you ought to avoid while baking your pie include: McIntosh, Golden delicious and Red delicious. On the other hand, the best apples for baking your pie should be firm and a little ripe. Such apples include: Jonagold, Crispin, Winesap, Macoun, Fuji, Jonathan and Granny Smith.

3. Stewed pie

Stewed pie

If you notice that your apple pie is stewing in its own juices, then it is not properly baked. Stewing happens when the butter in the crust melts and instead of evaporating, it finds its way to the dough. The only remedy for this situation is baking at the right temperature. Apple pies require high temperatures for them to bake well.

Before you embark on baking, you need to ensure that you preheat your oven to 425 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. Once the oven is hot enough place your pie and after 30 minutes, bring the temperature down to 350-375 degrees Fahrenheit. Allow the pie to bake until it has turned golden brown and the filling starts bubbling.

4. Dry Crust

You might get the entire process right but fail in handling the dough. Dough is a key ingredient in baking apple pies and hence should be handled gently. Overworking the dough causes it to become gummy. Such an error can affect the entire process and the best way to avoid it is to use cold ingredients. The cold ingredients will ensure that the dough relaxes and hold together. Be sure to use ice cold water and refrigerated butter. If you want, you can also chill the flour and the mixing bowl. To determine whether your dough is properly done, you should be able to notice streaks of butter on the dough.

5. Air spaces on pie

Air spaces on your pie are a result of using huge pieces of apple. These huge chunks interfere with heat circulation hence forcing the top layer to harden before the filling is fully cooked. The filling will shrink and create air spaces. The solution to such a predicament is cutting the apples into small and thin pieces. Alternatively, you can first cook the pie before adding the filling.


Making the perfect pie can be a tedious undertaking. Nevertheless, you still stand a chance of baking an apple pie that surpasses your expectations. All you need is to understand the causative agents and how to fix an undercooked apple pie.

Related posts:

Leave a Comment